One True Google Phone? I’m Skeptical, But Hopeful

By  |  Tuesday, October 20, 2009 at 12:10 pm

Google PhoneTheStreet’s Scott Mortiz is reporting that Google plans to sell a phone of its own. The device will supposedly run Android (of course) and will go on sale at retail stores this year (and hey, that means soon–there isn’t very much 2009 left). It would be an unlocked phone that would run on AT&T, T-Mobile, and most carriers around the world, and Google is supposedly undertaking the project to get more control over the integration of the device with its own services.

Moritz based his story on a report by analyst Ashok Kumar, who says he’s spoken with hardware companies involved in bringing the product to market. According to this GigaOM post, Kumar also says that Google will release a netbook (presumably running Chrome OS) next year, and that both the phone and the netbook will use Qualcomm’s Snapdragon CPU.

Despite the confident tone of Mortiz’s piece, my instinct is to be skeptical about the prospect of Google entering the phone business. Android is starting to take off as a platform, thanks to its enthusiastic adoption by a whole bunch of companies, including Verizon, Motorola, HTC, and others. Wouldn’t they rather see Google as a partner rather than a competitor? Even if Google went to extreme lengths to avoid giving preferential treatment to its own device, it would be bound to leave other Android supporters feeling uneasy, and possibly eyeing other options.

Then there’s the notion that the Googlephone would be sold unlocked, not through carriers. I’m a fan of unlocked phones myself, and will happily pay a premium for ’em. But the market for unlocked phones is tiny–in the U.S., anyhow–because prices are so much higher than the deals you can get by signing up for a contract. Google being Google, it might pull a game-changing move that would result in an affordable unlocked phone, but you gotta think that doing that would make its partners even unhappier.

I may be doubtful, but I hope Google does release its own phone. Aside from the wealth of iPhone apps, the iPhone’s greatest advantage over the competition is the sheer seamlessness of its integration of hardware device and the iTunes-related services. Many companies try to ape Apple’s level of hardware-software-service integration, and very few even come close. But it’s ultimately a noble goal, and I’d like to see what Google would do with Android if its only goal was to make the very best Google phone possible. It would drive other Android supporters bonkers, but it might (A) make consumers very happy, and (B) keep Apple on its toes…


Read more: , ,

2 Comments For This Post

  1. Tech Says:

    If it’s like anything else Google does it should be a good phone.

  2. marinelayer Says:

    I’m also somewhat skeptical. Why would Google undercut its partners just as it’s starting working relationships with them? It’s not as if those partners don’t eventually want to serve up their own low-end Android phones.

    Maybe it’s not a regular mobile phone. It might be a MID with VOIP and Google Voice. Or maybe it’s a normal cell phone partnership with Wal-Mart/TracFone on the StraightTalk service.

    The one major circumstantial issue is that Google has flirted with telephony before. The gPhone ended up being Android. Google made an initial bid in the 700 MHz auction but didn’t actually buy any spectrum. If Google actually bought some of that spectrum a phone followup would make sense. Since they didn’t they’d have little choice but to follow an MVNO model. Either way it’s a lot of overhead and headaches for information they could get much more easily through the existing services model.

5 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Resolved: The Best Gadgets Are the Work of One Company | Technologizer Says:

    […] positively working on an Android phone of its own for release early next year. He seems to be confirming scuttlebutt from a month ago, and the only thing that’s changed is that the shipping schedule has […]

  2. The Googlephone: What We Know, May Know, and Don’t Know | Technologizer Says:

    […] Googlephone, which has been around for years in one form or another and has recently appeared to be firming up into something that just might be real. Very little is official, but we know a few things for sure, more scuttlebutt has emerged, and […]

  3. Rumors, speculations and fact about new Google phone « Information SuperJunkie's Blog Says:

    […] Googlephone, which has been around for years in one form or another and has recently appeared to be firming up into something that just might be real. Very little is official, but we know a few things for sure, more scuttlebutt has emerged, and […]

  4. Coming Soon: Nexus One on Sprint Says:

    […] all the controversy over Google competing directly with its own partners, it’s doing a good job of getting the Nexus One onto all the big U.S. networks. ¬†Given that […]

  5. Google and Sprint Buddy Up on Nexus S, Google Voice Says:

    […] Googlephone. It’s a concept that sometimes sounds an exciting taste of the future, and sometimes sounds like it’s already fizzled. And today, it’s back to being […]