The Early iPhone 4S Reviews Are Here

By  |  Tuesday, October 11, 2011 at 11:20 pm

I don’t have an iPhone 4S yet, so I’ve been reading the first round of reviews from folks who got them ahead of the handset’s release this Friday. I don’t see any stunning conclusions. Everybody likes the phone either a lot or a lot, everybody’s impressed by the Siri voice assistant and likes the improved camera, and nobody’s overly traumatized by the fact that the case design hasn’t changed. As per Hallowed Technologizer Tradition, let’s look at the final paragraph (or two) of some of the reviews, which is the place where most reviewers finally tell you what they really think.

Walt Mossberg, The Wall Street Journal/AllThingsD.com

The iPhone 4S is one of Apple’s less dramatic updates, but, when combined with the Siri, iOS 5 and iCloud features, it presents an attractive new offering to smartphone users. Some may be content to skip the new hardware and just enjoy the software and cloud features with older models. But those buying the phone will likely be happy with it.

David Pogue, The New York Times

The question isn’t what’s in a name — it’s what’s in a phone. And the answer is: “A lot of amazing technology. And some of it feels like magic.”

Ed Baig, USA Today

Apple concedes that Siri isn’t a finished product; she is in beta. But even with her blemishes, Siri is pretty darn cool. And she helps make the iPhone 4S pretty darn cool, too.

Jason Snell, Macworld

In the end, the iPhone 4S follows Apple’s recent trajectory of iPhone releases: It’s an object of some appeal to people who last upgraded their phones a year ago, and over the next year a great many of them will find it worthwhile to upgrade to the iPhone 4S. But to all those people who’ve been hanging on to their iPhone 3G or iPhone 3GS, the wait is over: It’s time to upgrade without any hesitation whatsoever. The iPhone 4S has speed, a great camera, some cool voice-recognition features, and the same beautiful industrial design that was introduced in the iPhone 4. It’s destined to be immensely popular. The S, in this case, seems to stand for “sure thing.”

Joshua Topolsky, This is My Next
Is this the best phone ever made? That’s debatable. But I can tell you this: the iPhone 4S is pretty damn cool.

MG Siegler, TechCrunch

I’m happy that Apple decided not to change the form factor even though they had to know there would be some backlash from a certain segment of the population (read: idiots). Instead, Apple focused on the other thing they do best: refining already great products to make them better. The iPhone 4 was a great product. The best smartphone ever made. Now it cedes that title to the iPhone 4S.

John Gruber, Daring Fireball

The iPhone 4 was my favorite product that Apple has ever made. The iPhone 4S has all the best features of the iPhone 4 — same look, same feel, same Retina Display — and adds several significant improvements.

Stephen Fry, The Guardian

Once again Apple is taking a lead and asking a lot of its competitors. I wish those competitors luck, for the better all smartphones are, the happier I am. If Steve Jobs’s true legacy is that the devices every other company makes are so, so much better than they otherwise would have been, I don’t think he would mind one bit.

Vincent Nguyen, Slashgear

There will undoubtedly be smartphones with faster processors, or more megapixels to their cameras, or high-speed 4G connectivity, or bigger, better resolution displays, but it’s difficult to imagine any of them competing with the joined-up ecosystem Apple now offers. Challenging the iPhone isn’t just about creating one single, better smartphone, but a portfolio of consistent products and services. The iPhone 4S may look the same as before, but it arguably represents just as much of a shift in the industry as the original iPhone ever did.

Brian X .Chen, Wired (Brian waxes philosophical in his final paragraph, so I’m including his next-to-last one, too)

The iPhone 4S looks exactly the same as its predecessor — but who cares? If it was shaped even slightly differently or came in a new color, people would still go nuts over the stuff that’s more important anyway: the insides. And both inside and out, this is a magnificent smartphone.

The late Steve Jobs once called the computer the equivalent of a bicycle for our minds. I think of the smartphone as the rocket ship for our minds. With increasingly powerful sensors and technologies, and access to hundreds of thousands of apps enabling us to do just about anything, the iPhone keeps soaring to incredible heights and taking us to places with limitless potential. I guess that’s what you have to do to create a ding in the universe.

Jim Dalrymple, The Loop (Jim, have two short paragraphs, won’t you?)

You can look at each of the items that Apple will release in conjunction with the iPhone and be amazed with how innovative all of them are.

When you put them all together in one product like the iPhone 4S, you have an incredibly successful product that other companies just can’t compete with.


I wonder if these will calm down folks who think that the iPhone 4S is a disappointment? Stay tuned for more reviews to come–including mine.

 
12 Comments


Read more: , ,

12 Comments For This Post

  1. iPhone 4 Application Says:

    iPhone 4 is Very Good just like i expected .

  2. MJPollard Says:

    Actually, all this does is convince me that no matter what Apple does, the tech press will gush over it like schoolgirls with crushes on the latest boy band. :-)

  3. Paul Says:

    do we still have to use ITunes? Yes, than I don't want one. Apple can innovate all they like with the phone as long as that piece of crapware is involved I will probably never buy an Apple product.

  4. NanoGeek Says:

    With iCloud you technically don't need to, but it would be a bit clumsy to use.

  5. @WaltFrench Says:

    Maybe the RDF only kept the naysayers at bay until the reviews came out. I remember the iPad intro as tentative, “we think maybe there's room for a third device,” followed by all the guffawing … for a couple of days.

    Looks like the same story here: skeptics gotta dismiss stuff they can't touch, but once the device shows up in regular people's hands, a balanced impression emerges.

    Too bad my original iPhone4 got destroyed (an accident that would take out ANY electronics) and I'm only a couple of months into the replacement. I'll have to watch from the sidelines.W

  6. Andy Lee Says:

    Typo alert: I'm guessing "I've been the first" should have been "I've been reading the first".

  7. Sir Fatty Says:

    Those aren’t reviews as much as Apple fans talking about the device. Couldn’t find a dissenting view? Did you try to find one?

  8. Harry McCracken Says:

    I included nearly every review published so far, to my knowledge. I saw no negative ones.

  9. Shane Brady Says:

    An announcement can be a disappointment not necessarily mean it's a bad product. I think an objective look at the iPhone 4S will show that it's a good phone, a decent upgrade, but not really that much better than the competition. If you're an Apple user, that's prolly fine.

    As for sales numbers equaling quality, just remember Transformers 2 made 800M.

  10. Damon Says:

    I love my iPhone 4S! I got it yesterday and I haven’t put it down ever since they opened the box for me. I had a Droid X and was so tired of all the bugs that it had. My friend let me try out his iPhone 4, and it made me want to try out an iPhone! I ordered my iPhone 4S as soon as it was available and so far, this is the best phone I’ve ever had! I love streaming shows, and it was good to know that the DISH Remote Access app that I used on my Droid is available for the iPhone. I love streaming movies and shows and this app lets me do just that! It lets me stream live TV and recorded shows from my 922 SlingLoaded receiver to my phone anywhere I am! It has been so much smoother on my iPhone. As a customer and employee of DISH Network, I have been using the app on my Droid for a long time, and now that I’ve had the opportunity to use it on my iPhone, I love it even more! I will never use Android again!

  11. Tea Kettles Says:

    do we still have to use ITunes? Yes, than I don't want one. Apple can innovate all they like with the phone as long as that piece of crapware is involved I will probably never buy an Apple product.

  12. Alarm clocks Says:

    How is this possible ? do we still have to use ITunes? Yes, than I don't want one. Apple can innovate all they like with the phone as long as that piece of crapware is involved I will probably never buy an Apple product.