The PalmPilots That Never Were

Over the years, Palm made some really cool products--and considered making some really weird ones.

Posted by  | Thursday, April 29, 2010


Wireless Phone With Removable Personal Information Manager

Filed May 29th, 1998

This curio–patented years before the first real Palm-based phone appeared–was for a StarTac-esque clamshell cell phone with a PDA you could pull off and use separately. The connection between the two halves was in the form of a PC Card connector on the handset part, allowing you to also plug the phone into your laptop’s PC Card slot and use it as a wireless modem.



Slides: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

14 Comments For This Post

  1. FSX Says:

    I think #11 was actually built; I have one if I remember correctly.

  2. Anon Says:

    The slideshow layout is complete crap. Everything in all 11 “pages” (which exist only to increase advertising serving ratios) could have just as well been one single long page. And had it been one single long page it would have been more useful and I would have bothered to have read through the entire site. As it is, I’m leaving after page 1.

  3. Makea Says:

    I have # 11 in my hand right now. atached to my lifedrive. it was a real product

  4. LarrySDonald Says:

    The joypad would make more sense if you could just plain push the whole stylus into a depression and use it as a joystick rather then unscrewing it.

  5. eep Says:

    #5: “a Webcam-equipped, multimedia-enabled PDA that permitted for videoconferencing and WebEx-like online meetings. Neat–and probably a tad ahead of its time given that the patent dates to 2002, before the dawn of 3G broadband and modern smartphones. Even in 2010, I’m not sure if we have anything quite this ambitious.”

    How about the huge pile of smartphones that have a camera on the same face as the screen, for video conferencing? My Nokia has one. So did my last Nokia. I can (for example) pull up a PowerPoint presentation and watch it during the video conference, or have the web browser open and connect to a web-based conferencing system. Plenty of phones can do this. It’s actually a pretty good idea.

  6. Mike Says:

    I like split keyboards; they work well, either in fold-out form factors, or on tablets. One major problem with the iPad is that its on-screen keyboard is too large to thumb-type on. Splitting it into a left and right half on-screen keyboard would fix that.

  7. Denis Bergeron Says:

    #6, is from Isaac Asimov’s “End of eternity” novel.

  8. Ryan Says:

    I also had #11, worked quite well. I used it for taking notes in class–far more portable than any laptop of the day.

  9. Harry McCracken Says:

    I had and liked a Palm folding keyboard myself–they sold one based on the Stowaway, and then later their own design–but did they ever have one with a numeric keypad like that?

  10. Cosgrach Says:

    #9 is a wigi board.

  11. andy Says:

    #9 = digital Ouija board

  12. Greg Flores Says:

    I used to carry a Palm III C, and a Motorola Star-Tac phone, felt kind of like a member of the crew of the Enterprise. When palm first put the Palm OS on a clam shell style phone, (I don’t remember the name though) I wanted that phone so bad, but the phone never really took off.

    Then, they came out with the Treo. WOW! (I still have my 600, 700, & 755)
    I also have the IR version of the folding keyboard, and you’re right. Great for taking notes in class and sending text messages during lectures (never got caught), just had to turn off the speaker and the vibrate.

  13. Bailey Singh Says:

    Video Conferencing is really a very convenient and very fast way in keeping in touch with your business partners..:.

  14. dave Says:

    No 9 application unclear? Far as I recall, it's for communicating with the dead.

8 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. HP gains some weird patents with Palm purchase | LogicHP - HP Laptop Coupons, Deals, Reviews, News, and Forum Says:

    [...] are the rights of everything they have made, as well as everything that Palm has not. According to Technologizer (vis Gizmodo), HP now has patent to a whole slew of bizzare and silly patents of phones that were, [...]

  2. The Weird Palm Patents HP Will Soon Own | Gizmodo Australia Says:

    [...] McCracken has gone through the trouble of compiling some of these PalmPilots that never were over on Technologizer. Most were filed in the 1990s and they range from the curious yet sensible, like a wall mounted [...]

  3. The PalmPilots That Never Were | JetLib News Says:

    [...] that converts into a joystick, and pre-Treo hybrids of phone and PDA that just didn’t work. I rounded up some fascinating examples.” It’s worth clicking through the obnoxious slide-show format to see [...]

  4. Patentando el cielo | Federratas Says:

    [...] de Palm por parte de Hewlett-Packard el sitio Technologizer publicó un artículo mostrando patentes que ilustran las ideas que Palm exploró en su historia. El artículo está presentado de una manera muy molesta (hay que visitar 11 páginas [...]

  5. Palm 那些失落的有趣创意 | ifanr 爱范儿 ♂专注于拇指设备的小众讨论 Says:

    [...] HTC 和 Nokia 垂涎的专利也是 HP 的一大收获。前些日子 Technologizer 挑选了一些 Palm 专利中未曾实现的内容与我们分享。下面就让我们看看 Palm [...]

  6. And That’s What You Missed on Technologizer Says:

    [...] I also used the HP-Palm deal as an excuse to look at old Palm patents for devices which were never built. [...]

  7. Ein Android-Konkurrent weniger: HP stellt WebOS und TouchPad ein | androidnext Says:

    [...] ist auch das Patent-Portfolio (obwohl Palms Ideen zuweilen recht skurril waren) aus dem Palm-Nachlass sehr interessant für andere Konzerne. Das dürfte bereits beim [...]

  8. Tien Palm pda’s die nooit uitgebracht zijn | webOSclub Says:

    [...] Een telefoon, waar je het pda-deel van kon loskoppelen [...]