By Harry McCracken | Sunday, April 11, 2010 at 12:48 pm
Must be a quiet weekend in the blogosphere: One of the major topics of discussion is how Apple chooses the times shown in stock images of its products–which happen to be 9:41am in photos of the iPad and 9:42am in ones of the iPhone 3GS.
As Network World and Fast Company noticed, Secret Lab developer Jon Manning blogged that he ran into iPhone software honcho Scott Forstall at the Palo Alto Apple Store, and Forstall said that the times are chosen to sync as closely as possible with the moment in Apple press events when the product is shown for the first time:
We design the keynotes so that the big reveal of the product happens around 40 minutes into the presentation. When the big image of the product appears on screen, we want the time shown to be close to the actual time on the audience’s watches. But we know we won’t hit 40 minutes exactly…for the iPhone, we made it 42 minutes. It turned out we were pretty accurate with that estimate, so for the iPad, we made it 41 minutes. And there you are – the secret of the magic time.
Mystery solved! What revealing proof of Apple’s perfectionism! Betcha that Microsoft doesn’t sweat details like that!
Except…it’s not nearly that simple. In order to actually figure this stuff out, you need to revisit the video of Apple’s keynotes, track when the “big reveals” occur, and take note of the time as indicated in the images shown onstage.
So I did. And I found that the iPhone 3GS was announced at approximately 11:45am at last year’s WWDC. And the iPad was unveiled at roughly 10:10am at an event in January. In neither case did the time shown in the “big reveal” image have anything to do with the current time in San Francisco, where both products debuted.
Just to complicate matters: The “big reveal” image of the iPhone 3GS showed the time as 9:41am, the same one indicated by the iPad–I’m not sure where the 9:42am shown in current stock images of the iPhone 3GS came from.
It’s clear that someone at Apple likes the time 9:41.am: At last Thursday’s iPhone OS 4 event, Steve Jobs showed a still image of the Netflix app, and again it showed that time even though it was 10:17am in Cupertino. (As with most Apple events, the press briefing didn’t even begin until 10am.)
So does 9:41 mean anything? Yes. Here’s a clue: It was the time shown on the first iPhone during its “big reveal” back in January of 2007 at Macworld Expo:
Jobs was forty minutes into the keynote, which had been scheduled to begin at 9am–which fits Forstall’s “big reveal” theory exactly. But the keynote had gotten off to an unusually slow start, and didn’t get underway until 9:14 or so. So Jobs stood onstage at 9:54am with a picture of an iPhone that seemed to be keeping really bad time.
In other words, it would seem that Apple tried for obsessive perfectionism, but it didn’t quite work out.
Why have later images in Apple keynotes kept the 9:41am time even though it no longer has any relation to the real time? Well, I wouldn’t be surprised if the failure of the “big reveal” time sync in 2007 to actually work led the company to give up on the idea. And maybe it kept the 9:41am as a lucky charm. Other theories welcome. (Including ones on why iPhone 3GS images now have the time at 9:42am.)
A few further notes on Apple images and the time of day:
1) It’s also 9:42am on current iPad Nano images:
2) In current Apple stock photos of Macs, it’s always 10:50am on Monday (whether or not this ties into any past “big reveal,” I’m not sure):
3) If you’re interested in contributing to this important research, you might look into whether there was any consistency in the time shown in Apple stock photos prior to 2007. For starters, here’s the day and time as shown in a 2002 ad for the second-generation “desk lamp” iMac:
4) For decades, most watch ads have shown watches that indicate the time as 10:10 or thereabouts (sometimes a couple of minutes earlier, sometimes a couple of minutes later). There’s no conspiracy–it’s just that it looks attractive, and artfully places the hands so that they don’t interfere with the manufacturer’s logo. But the iPad’s big reveal in January did happen at 10:10am–maybe that’s a conspiracy!
5) It’s now 12:48pm local time on Sunday. I think I’ll have lunch…