By Steve Bass | Wednesday, March 24, 2010 at 8:05 pm
There’s been a big kerfuffle since the FCC recently proposed to give broadband a goose.
If the National Broadband Plan goes as it should (and no, I’m not counting on it, either), almost everyone in the U.S. will get high-speed Internet access (the goal is 90% coverage); average speeds will increase by 20%; and everyone will get malware and viruses lots more quickly.
As it is, the U.S. is near the bottom of the broadband pile, with speeds averaging 2.5- to 10-megabits per second (Mbps); Japan, France, and Korea lead the pack at warp speeds ranging from 160 to 100-Mbps. Read BusinessWeek’s World’s Fastest Broadband; check some numbers from 2007; and if you’re a hard-core techie, dive into some OECD specs from 2009.
The dust-up happened when the FCC said most of us are paying for an “up to” speed, but not always getting nearly that advertised rate. The FCC offered to test your bandwidth speed. That’s nice, except it uses two testing services and the results at the sites vary, sometimes substantially. (Read How fast is your broadband? Even the feds can’t be sure in the L.A. Times. (Thanks for this, Barry.)
For comparison, I downloaded a 700MB file using JDownloader at 7:00 am, noon, and 5:00 pm. I clocked my Charter Communication cable connection and throughput was consistent: It stayed mostly at 350 kilobits per second (Kbps) with lots of bursts as high as 460 Kbps. In megabits per second, that’s 2.8 Mbps with bursts as high as 3.7 Mbps. (Techies: That’s based on 350 kilobits per second = 350 Kbps = 8*350 = 2800 Kbps = 2.8 Mbps.)
With any speed test, resist the temptation to check e-mail or browse the Web while testing so as not to alter the results.
If any of the online tests I’ve listed this week won’t work, you might need the most current version of Flash Player and Java. (Start on the Java site, click the “Free Java Download link,” and then click the “Download Java Now” button for Windows. And be careful: During the installation, make sure to deselect the Yahoo toolbar option. [top]
BroadBand DSLReports: The granddaddy of online testing, DSLReports gives you a stack of tests to try. The Speed Test (choose the “Flash 8 plugin based speed test”) has a cool speedometer that displays your upload and download speeds. You can test your speed by using any of six servers in different locations. You’ll get a good average by testing with two: Try one close to home and another across the country.
Line quality test: If you’re worried about your connection, use the Line Quality test to look for packet loss and excessive latency. If you register and log in when testing, and then come back for another test, you can compare results between tests
SpeedTest: The site is powered by Ookla, one of the two tests that the feds use–and which the L.A. Times article implies overestimates results. But Speedtest is quicker to get to than DSLReports and is has an oh-so-nifty auto dashboard-like interface, the kind you want to show off when friends are in your office.
If your Internet connection is really sluggish, like emulating dialup, consider doing a couple of the tests I mentioned this week every hour or two for a few days–and keep a log. If you’re getting nowhere near advertised rates, send the results to your ISP — and raise a high-speed ruckus.
If you complain vigorously, and can substantiate your complaint with test results, chances are good, or at least better, that you’ll get some help.
And it could be something simple causing the problem. Here are a few typical issues (and solutions) to high-speed hassles:
[This post is excerpted from Steve's TechBite newsletter. If you liked it, head here to sign up--it's delivered on Wednesdays to your inbox, and it's free.]