iPhone App Store Approval Process: Apple’s Whitewater?

By  |  Friday, August 28, 2009 at 3:55 pm

The appearance of wrong doing can create a perception that trumps reality. Apple has needlessly tarnished its reputation in the industry by shrouding its iPhone App Store approval process in secrecy, fomenting speculation that it is deeply flawed and unfair. Only transparency will rebuild trust.

It took Apple eleven days to certify Facebook 3.0, which debuted on App Store yesterday. That’s less time than the two-week period that Apple says 95 percent of apps are approved within. But Facebook is one of the App Store’s most popular programs, and lots of iPhone owners were waiting for the new version.

Apple’s prolonged approval process drew the ire of lead developer Joe Hewitt, who blogged publicly about his frustrations and said even two weeks are two weeks too many. Facebook is a high profile App Store developer, and Hewitt’s criticism cast a negative light on Apple that was intensified by press reports.

It might seem like an odd comparison, but I’m reminded of the Whitewater investigation that plagued much of the Clinton presidency. A friend who used to work in the White House told me that one senior adviser told the President that the scandal would be defused if he made documents available for review. Secrecy is what gave Whitewater a life of its own, and the President’s opponents exploited the ensuing distrust.

Apple has had numerous Whitewater moments. There are numerous rejected apps, and there isn’t always a clear reason behind Apple’s refusal to publish them. Now the FCC is investigating Apple, and Microsoft is appealing to forsaken Apple developers to develop for Windows Mobile.

Like the Clinton administration before it, nothing is stopping Apple from clearing the air– except for its deeply rooted penchant for secrecy. If Apple can embrace transparency, it might even come off looking good. The perception couldn’t get much worse.

The company has said that every app undergo a security review. That’s great–I’d like to hear more about it and other steps that Apple takes to deliver quality applications for the iPhone. Until it does, the controversy will continue.


Read more: , ,

2 Comments For This Post

  1. Marc Says:

    Out of all applications, the ones that millions of people use, like Facebook should be tested the most.

  2. iPhone Apps Says:

    I love how the Facebook people think they deserve special treatment. Sorry guys, but if the lowly developer putting out a candle simulator app must wait two weeks, then so should you. Actually, the Facebook app should see a longer wait because it has so much functionality!

3 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Fred Trotter » The iphone, a poor HIT platform analogy Says:

    […] Apple elsewhere. The approval process is slow, painful and does not make sense most importantly people hate it. The problem is that you have to have an approval process, and the reason that Apple is so closed […]

  2. 2 Billion Downloads Later, Apple’s App Store is Still Going Strong | Social Nibble Says:

    […] developers, no matter the grumblings about the App Store approval process, the App Store is simply the largest and most lucrative […]

  3. 2 Billion Downloads Later, Apple’s App Store is Still Going Strong : Apple iPod Touch 8 GB 3rd Generation best iTouch 32GB Newest Model Says:

    […] developers, no concern the grumblings most the App Store support process, the App Store is only the maximal and most profitable activity […]